Metuchen Real Estate

Architectural Styles & Housing Stock

Metuchen offers a diverse array of housing that reflects its development over the last century. Unlike the cookie-cutter subdivisions found in many suburbs, Metuchen’s streets are eclectic and tree-lined.

• Victorian & Colonial Revival: Near Main Street and the older sections of town ("Hillside"), you will find beautifully preserved Victorian homes from the late 19th and early 20th centuries, often featuring wrap-around porches and intricate woodwork.

• The Radio Section: This distinct neighborhood is dominated by charming Cape Cods, Tudors, and pre-war Colonials, highly sought after for its quiet, storybook atmosphere.

• Mid-Century: Further from the downtown core, you will find split-levels and ranch-style homes built during the post-WWII boom, offering more practical layouts and often larger backyards.

• New Construction: There has been a recent wave of luxury townhomes and condos near the train station, catering to commuters who prefer modern amenities and zero maintenance.

​​

The Schools: A "Blue Ribbon" Standard

The Metuchen School District is a major draw for families. It is small enough that teachers know students by name, but large enough to offer competitive academic and extracurricular programs.

• Edgar Middle School: Designated a National Blue Ribbon School in 2022.

• Metuchen High School: Consistently highly rated, known for its strong AP program and exceptional music and arts department.

• Private Options: St. Francis Cathedral School (Pre-K through 8th) is located right in town and was also named a Blue Ribbon School (2017).

​​

Real Estate Market: Prices for Sale & Rent

Demand in Metuchen has outpaced supply for several years, driving prices upward. The market is competitive, with many homes receiving multiple offers shortly after listing.

• For Sale: As of late 2024/early 2025, the median sales price for a single-family home in Metuchen hovers between $750,000 and $830,000.

  • Entry-level: Smaller Capes or fix-upper colonials can sometimes be found in the $550,000 – $650,000 range.

  • Luxury/Historic: Large, renovated Victorians or new builds frequently sell for $1.1 million to $1.5 million+.

• For Rent:

  • 1-Bedroom Apartment: $2,100 – $2,600/month.

  • Whole House Rental: $3,500 – $4,500+/month depending on size and condition.

​

The Commute to NYC

The direct train line is the borough's single greatest asset.

• Train: The Metuchen Station is on NJ Transit’s Northeast Corridor Line.

• Time: Express trains can reach New York Penn Station in roughly 45–50 minutes. The station is located right in the center of town, making it walkable for many residents.

• Driving: Metuchen is strategically located near the Garden State Parkway, I-287, and the NJ Turnpike.

​​

Safety & Community

Metuchen is widely considered a safe place to live. Violent crime is extremely rare, and the borough has an active police department involved in community policing, often seen at the many street fairs, farmers markets, and art festivals.

​​

Metuchen Property Value Appreciation Chart (2015-2025)